Licensee Karen Murphy has lost her High Court battle to use a foreign broadcaster rather than the more expensive BSky-B to screen Premiership football games for customers at her Red, White and Blue pub in Southsea, Hampshire. But two judges gave Murphy, who was convicted by Portsmouth magistrates of criminal copyright theft, permission to reopen her appeal. The Independent 22/12/07 page 18 The Times 22/12/07 page 4